That is what we are supposed to do when we are at our best - make it all up - but make it up so truly that later it will happen that way.Ernest Hemingway
We have 684 registered Members.There are no Members online.There are 14 Guests online.
I'm not the ideal audience for this one, because while I am not opposed to
fantasy genre games, I rarely enjoy those which style themselves after RPG
Threnody exudes authorial good will and seems technically adequate -- in a
few respects, more than adequate. I appreciated touches like the enhanced status
bar and the magic self-updating map.
On the other hand, the setting, and the writing that described it,
disappointed me. It struck me as fairly stock fantasy material, the author not
having given a lot of time to developing his world as a place with its own
history and character. And once or twice -- as when the passageway collapsed
behind me -- I had the impression that he was trying to apologize for having
just relied on a tremendous clich. This almost never works; if you realize that
one of your plot mechanics is overused, better to take it out and replace it
with something more interesting and more specifically suited to the story.
I played about a hundred moves before losing energy and interest. Points for
accepting >FIAT LUX as a command. But the bottom line is that it takes
tremendous writing skill to get me to accept a talking cat without rolling my
IFReviewer RatingName Emily ShortGender Female
- 1981- A Paper Moon- A Party to Murder- A Stop For The Night- Adoo's Stinky Story - Amnesia- Anchorhead- ASCII and the Argonauts- Augmented Fourth- August- Augustine- Authority- Baluthar- Bedlam- Bio- Black Sheep's Gold- BOFH- Bolivia By Night- Cerulean Stowaway- Choose Your Own Romance- Common Ground- Concrete Paradise- Constraints- Delvyn- Domicile- Doomed Xycanthus- Earth and Sky 2: Another Earth, Another Sky- Elizabeth Hawke's Forever Always- Episode In The Life Of An Artist- Eric's Gift- Evacuate- Fallacy of Dawn- First Things First- Flametop- Flat Feet- Friendly Foe- Gourmet- Hell: A Comedy of Errors- Hercules First Labor- Identity Thief- Internal Documents- Jane- Janitor- Katana- Last Ride of the Night- MythTale- No Room- Not Much Time- Ogres- One Week- Out of the Study- Queen of Swords- Ramon and Jonathan- Redemption- Rematch- Risorgimento Represso- Sardoria- Scavenger- Screen- Shadows on the Mirror- Slouching Towards Bedlam- So Far- Sparrow's Song- Spider and Web- Sun and Moon- Swanglass- Temple of Kaos- Textfire Golf- The Adventures of the President Of The United States- The Atomic Heart- The Battle of Walcot Keep- The Case of Samuel Gregor- The Coast House- The Erudition Chamber- The Fire Tower- The Granite Book- The Land of the Cyclops- The Moonlit Tower- The Recruit- The Tarot Reading- The Weapon- Till Death Makes a Monk-Fish Out of Me!- Tookie's Song- Unraveling God- Voices- Whom The Telling Changed